There is a common assumption in the NFP sector that you either rely on external HR support or you build in house capability. Our experience of more than 30 years alongside NFP organisations is that the best organisations do both, and the ones who do it well know exactly which problems belong in each column.
This post is the companion to our earlier piece on why small NFPs struggle with HR. That post was about diagnosing the problem. This one is about what comes next, for organisations that are ready to build internal HR capacity and want to do it without creating new risks in the process.
The risk in building in house too fast
We have watched organisations make the same mistake more than once. They reach a point where their HR needs have grown, higher headcount, more regulatory complexity, a workforce that needs more than the CEO can give it, and they hire an internal HR manager, hand over responsibility, and step back.
6 months later, the internal manager is across the day to day but struggling with the complex situations. The CEO has lost visibility of HR risk because it is now “someone else’s area.” The organisation is paying for an in house function that cannot fully replace the specialist depth it had through external support, and it is uncertain how to fix that without implying the hire was a mistake.
The hire itself is usually sound. The problem is the model of transition. Handing over HR entirely, in one move, to a single internal hire, without a plan for how specialist depth is maintained, creates a capability gap that is invisible until something goes wrong.
The 3 stages of in house HR maturity
In our experience working alongside NFP organisations as they build internal HR capability, organisations tend to move through 3 stages. Understanding where you are helps you plan the next move.
Stage 1: Foundations
At this stage, the organisation has no dedicated HR function. HR is managed by the CEO, operations manager, or a coordinator with other primary responsibilities. The priority is building the foundational infrastructure, including a compliant HR policy suite, position descriptions, a classification framework, onboarding processes, and a supervision structure.
External support at this stage is most valuable when it builds these foundations and transfers the tools and knowledge to the internal team. The goal is to equip the organisation to manage the foundations independently.
Stage 2: Growing capability
At this stage, the organisation has an internal HR presence, often a part time coordinator or a full time generalist, who manages the day to day. The foundations are in place. The challenge is that complex situations still require specialist depth that the internal resource does not always have.
External support at this stage works best as a retainer or on call arrangement, available when the complex situation arrives (a grievance, an Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission audit, a restructure, a difficult performance matter) but unnecessary for the day to day. This keeps costs proportionate while maintaining access to the depth that complex situations demand.
Stage 3: Strategic partnership
At this stage, the organisation has an established internal HR function, a Head of People and Culture or equivalent, with real capability across the operational and strategic domains. The internal team can manage most situations independently. External support is engaged for specific projects: a workforce planning strategy, a leadership development program, a classification review under Award change, an organisational design process.
The relationship with external specialists at this stage is collaborative. The internal team leads; the external specialist contributes depth and independence on specific questions.
What capability transfer actually looks like
The phrase “building capability” is used a lot in consulting. It means different things in different contexts. Here is what it means to us at Pebbl., and what it looks like in practice.
It means that when we complete an HR audit, we walk through the findings with the internal team, explain the reasoning behind each recommendation, and ensure the team understands what to fix, why it matters, and how to prevent it recurring.
It means that when we develop an HR policy, we explain the regulatory context behind each provision, so the internal team can maintain and update it as regulations change.
It means that when we support a complex grievance process, we involve the internal team throughout, in an active role, and we debrief fully on the elements that required specialist input. The next similar situation should require less external support, and the team should feel the difference.
This is what the Side by Side principle means in practice. We are here to leave your team stronger than we found it, every time.
The questions worth asking now
If you are thinking about building internal HR capability, these are the questions worth working through before you act.
- What does your HR function actually need to do? Map the HR activities your organisation requires, routine compliance, complex situations, strategic workforce planning, leadership development. Which of these can and should be internal? Which require specialist depth that is better accessed externally?
- What is the right pace? Transitioning too fast creates the capability gap described above. Transitioning too slowly creates dependence that becomes hard to unwind. The right pace is usually slower than organisations expect, particularly where the regulatory environment is complex and changing.
- How will you maintain access to specialist depth? Even fully mature internal HR functions benefit from external specialist support on specific questions. Plan for this from the beginning as a deliberate feature of a sophisticated HR model.
- What does success look like in 2 years? Define it. Headcount, compliance position, leadership capability, workforce data quality. Then work backwards from that picture to the investments you need to make now.
We have helped organisations at every stage of this journey, from the CEO managing HR alone to the organisation building its first dedicated people function to the mature provider designing a workforce strategy for a complex multi site operation. If you are thinking through your next step, we are a useful sounding board.
About Pebbl.
Pebbl. (formerly ANSON Management Consulting) has supported organisations for more than 30 years, and today works with aged care, disability and community services organisations across workforce planning, HR compliance, leadership development and organisational design. Everything we do is built around one principle, prevention over reaction.